Imitate the Good

October 4, 2026
Imitate the Good
Imitate the Good
Imitate the Good
0:000:00

Imitate the Good

3 John


I’m not much of a letter writing. Never was. And my handwriting is atrocious, so when I do write, I have to type or print for my letter to be readable. When I was a child, my parents would send me to summer camp. My mom would take a stack of postcards, write our home address on them, put a stamp on them and pack them with my clothing. All I had to do was write some small thing on them and drop them in the mail. I usually got home with the stack of postcards intact. When Marsha and I were planning our wedding – rather she was in Beaverton planning the wedding and I was in Nampa studying – we’d write back and forth. When I went to England to study, I was gone for two weeks each time. I tried to send Marsha an email every day – if the computers were working. Sometimes, they weren’t. I think I’ve been pretty good about writing to here. Not so much to my parents or my siblings.   

Letter writing seems to almost be a lost art, particularly with the advent of email and instant messaging. Even telephone calls just to chat are rare these days. Some of you will remember when we had penmanship in school, so we could learn how to write legibly. We learned how to properly form the letters of the alphabet. Every classroom, remember, had those cards posted above the chalkboard with the letters, capital and uncial, to remind us how to form letters, especially in cursive. I think cursive is the secret code of our generation. But letter writing was not only common, but was the way people communicated across distance for centuries. It was a common literary form in John’s time. Writing materials were readily available, and though they were hard to work with compared to today’s paper, papyrus and vellum (leather), were available to virtually everyone.  

C. S. Lewis wrote about “chronological snobbery,” and lately I’ve been hearing about something called “presentism.” They are similar concepts. Lewis’s idea was that modern people thing we know better than those in the past. Modern ideas are superior to those of the past. We are better educated and far more literate. We tend to think of First Century people as uneducated and generally illiterate. The truth is that the literacy rate was quite high. Almost everyone in the Roman Empire could read and most could write, often in several languages. Presentism is the idea that those past generations should have known better. We know that slavery is wrong – they should have known. Pick just about any modern liberal idea and you will likely hear someone claim that those of the past should have known, and should have done better. It is arrogance. The truth is, I expect, that future generations will look back on us with the same condescension and suggest that we ought to have known better. If they knew what we knew. But they didn’t. And, in many ways, we are very wrong to look down on them. Some things they got right and we’ve got them wrong. Some things of the past were better than today.    

One of those things was communication. While we are fast, and while we are thoroughly connected, we have lost the human connections in our communication. We have a thousand friends on social media, but very few that we know in person and in whom we feel free to confide; few we can spend much leisure time with. We are more connected than ever in history, and incredibly lonely at the same time. It was letter writing that connected friends across the many miles. John’s letter to Gaius is an excellent example.  

3 John is a short letter, just 14 verses, but it is communication between friends. The NIV translates the address three times as “Dear friend.” But the Greek is best translated as “Beloved.” And there are three things happening here.

First, John commends his friend, Gaius, on his faithfulness in ministry and for his hospitality toward strangers. He begins with a prayer for good health and success: Beloved, I pray that you may enjoy good health and that all may go well with you. Then, he notes the reputation Gaius has built. There are some mutual friends who have come to John and told him about Gaius. Gaius is a church leader, perhaps a pastor, who is faithfully teaching the truth. There is a hint that Gaius may even be one of John’s own disciples, for he takes personal joy in hearing that my children are walking in the truth.   

Beloved, you are faithful in what you are doing for the brothers, even those who are strangers. Gaius’ hospitality toward strangers and foreigners is well known to John. How does he know? Because those travelers have reported to John the welcome they received from Gaius. We should note here that the strangers and foreigners John is talking about are traveling Christians. This is not any commentary on immigration. There were itinerant preachers, like Paul, and Christian’s who traveled for their business, like Lydia of Thyatira (Acts 16). Local Christians would open their homes to them. Part of hospitality, which John encourages here, included provisioning the traveler for the next leg of his journey, providing food and water, and often letters of commendation. We’ll come back to this in a moment.  

But John notes that there are particular travelers, itinerant preachers and missionaries, passing through, who are traveling specifically to preach Jesus. It was for the sake of the Name that they went out. They often went to areas that were hostile to the gospel, and they would certainly receive no such welcome, no such help from non-believers. There were many who saw Christianity as a threat to social order. Some considered it strange and subversive to preach one God, and especially that that one God had come to earth as a Man. The idea that they worshiped a criminal – because Jesus was crucified – was repugnant to many. They heard things that gave them strange ideas and fears about Christians. In some places, these itinerant preachers had been persecuted, beaten, and thrown out of town. Because of that, John notes, it is all the more important that the Church take care of its own. Because the world is hostile, it is vital that Christians find refuge among other Believers. In that way, we not only provide shelter and safety, but we also assist them in their ministries. Send them on their way with our blessing.

The second part of the letter is a warning. You have no doubt been in churches, or known churches, where there was a gatekeeper. I saw a video of a short play that depicted such a person. They want to be sure everything is done correctly in the church, even to the point of offering sermon notes to the pastor. I’ve had people say to me, “You should preach on this.” If God directs me, okay, but that’s not your decision. The gatekeeper tells people when she thinks they are wrong, and often not very kindly. He, or she, is the correcter, wanting to keep people in line. They are rule enforcers. They also decide who is welcome in the church. I’ve heard people say, “We don’t want their kind in our church,” often referring to single moms, alcoholics, or homeless. A church elder called the police on an alcoholic who just entered the church to pray and find hope. The church door is open or closed depending on the gatekeeper’s preferences. It may be because someone doesn’t dress “properly.” I saw a Catholic post suggesting that if you don’t dress “right” you’re not welcome in the worship service.   

Gaius’ church had such a person. The way John found out is that he had written to the church, planning a visit. Apparently, the gatekeeper, Diotrephes, wrote back telling John to stay away; he wouldn’t be welcome. Gaius probably didn’t even see the letter. In fact, as we read this little letter, we get the idea that Diotrephes was a problem Gaius didn’t know how to handle. He wanted to be in charge. John says, he loves to be first. He sits at the head table, runs the meetings, is first in line to the potluck, is the first to volunteer to head up a committee. And John lists the problems that Diotrephes causes:  

He is a gossip, spreading malicious nonsense about us, John says. They a subtle lies meant to make John look bad and himself look good. 

 He refuses to welcome the brothers. My translation says, “other believers.” That’s implied by the word brother. Fellow believers, itinerants and travelers, are treated coldly. 

And worse than his own cold reception is that he stands in the way of other people’s hospitality. Those who do welcome and bless their traveling brothers face Diotrephes’ wrath. If they dare to disobey him, John says, he puts them out of the church. If you don’t do it his way, he’ll kick you out. I hate to say it, but I’ve known a Diotrephes or two in my years of ministry. They are difficult to handle and resistant to correction.  

So, John has decided that he needs to visit Gaius’ church and expose Diotrephes. This will be a public censure in front of the church, calling him to account. Such a move will do two things: it will discipline Diotrephes, and it will serve as a warning to the rest of the church. Gossip is sin that has consequence for the entire church. The lack of hospitality, refusing to welcome other Believers, is sin that has consequences for the entire church – and especially when it is in the leadership, and especially when that leadership makes it a rule to be inhospitable. Gaius’ church, and maybe the modern church, needs this correction.

Beloved, do not imitate the evil but the good. Here’s the correction and the beginning of John’s third reason for writing. Don’t be like Diotrephes. Do good instead. Be hospitable. John uses an interesting word here when he writes anyone who does what is good is from God. That phrase, what is good, means to do the right thing or to be a good citizen. Hospitality was a cultural mandate. One who was hospitable, who welcomed strangers, was considered to be a good person, a proper citizen. John is essentially telling Gaius to give no occasion to the world around for criticism of the church or the gospel. Christians, Paul said, are to live in peace with their neighbors as much as possible without denying the faith (Rom 12:18). We are to be good citizens and do the right things. Anyone who does evil has not seen God. And evil, here, stands in contrast to doing right things.

But John is giving Gaius an opportunity to prove himself and to change the culture of the church that Diotrephes had created. John is sending Demetrius to visit, and encouraging Gaius to welcome him. He comes with a good reputation. John’s letter serves as a letter of commendation. People speak well of Demetrius. His life reflects the truth of the gospel so that John can say that even the truth itself commends him. Further, Demetrius is someone John knows. He says, we also speak well of him. That word, speak well, is a form of the word meaning witness. What John is saying is, “I can testify to his good character” and you know that my witness, my testimony is true. John puts his own character on the line. There may be a bit of a side-eye here. John notes the contrast between the two men - the wickedness of Diotrephes and the good character of Demetrius. He is telling Gaius to welcome, to be hospitable, and to be a blessing to Demetrius. But at the same time, without saying anything, John is telling Gaius to prevent Diotrephes from pulling his stunts against this particular guest. Don’t allow Diotrephes to bar the door to Demetrius. Throw open the door and welcome him as a brother.

Finally, as with the second letter, John has more to say, so when he comes to deal with Diotrephes, he will speak to Gaius face to face. The Greek here is more intimate, and hints at the close relationship. There are people who will misunderstand and misinterpret this, so I need to be very careful. The Greek reads, “mouth to mouth I will speak with you.” What that means is that John has things to say that are best said in person and in private. He could write. He could, he says, use pen and ink. There is much to say, but it is best communicated in person, face to face, rather than from a distance. And the desire is that John will be able to travel very soon. There is the sense, I think, that John misses the fellowship of his friend. In our world of long distance “instant messages”, e-mail, and social media, we are losing that personal connection. We argue behind the anonymity of social media, and say things we would never say face to face. The written word, the electronic word, is sterile and easily misunderstood. Even then, John knew that something is missing from long distance communication. We need the personal touch, the face-to-face relationship. We need eye-to-eye contact. 

Peace to you. The friends send their greetings. Greet the friends there by name. We are friends, after all. Let us act like it, and do right by one another.